Good question. The lack of other elements (Location, Year) will not influence my final decision. At the end of judging, I'd like to work with the Designer to add those elements in and get a finished front label. My main focus is as described above and elsewhere in this contest.
As a wine buyer, I like to see the location on the front label as well as the year. The grape varietal is not as important, I always look at the back label to get more detail. In fact, I want to keep the varietal off the front. Just in case the V series morphs into a Bordeoux Blend style (ie contains other varietals).
I may have another contest to design the back label. All the legalease about Country of Origin, Alcohol content, size of bottle, and other requirements can be on the back label.
Keep the front as clean as you can, if you want to include the location, "Franschhoek, South Africa" and that's it.
Because we produce such a small amount (~5,000 bottles) per year, the year will have to go on a separate small label on the front or on the capsule cover.