I really like #2. Its lines are simple and neat.
The more I think about it, the more I think I'd like to have the monstrance in the background, sort of glowing, with the school's name written in a layer on top of it. I like this glowing effect:
http://www.thecatholicshop.com/thumbnail.asp?file=/assets/images/PLT-768.jpg&maxx=300&maxy=0but would like to see it built into a monstrance, more like this:
http://daughtersofstdominic.org/images/monstrance_glow.jpgThe problem w/ that last one, though, is the background. The blue and purple are awful. I was hoping for a white or transparent background on the logo.
I like the burgundy in #2, but would rather pair it with a charcoal grey or caspian blue or french blue (or a hair darker).
Thank you very much!