Shamrock ComicsLogo Design Contest

I like the idea behind #7 but it reminds me to much of the 80's street graffiti.

I'm interested in seeing a design that incorporates something along the lines of the flogging molly logo. Maybe something like a circle with celtic knot as the border and then shamrock on the top, comics on the bottom & a shamrock in the middle.

#16 is pretty cool, but the middle looks too much like a button, according to a couple of friends that have checked it out. But I like where you were going with it

#19 & #20 remind me of a wreath...I still love the idea behind the celtic knot work, but it just doesn't seem to work in that format.

As for #21, the square logo doesn't hold the appeal as the others.

Thanks again everybody for your great submissions. I've been blown away so far by everything & am looking forward to seeing more.

Again, I can't say enough - Thank you to all.

#22-25 the leprechaun appears to have smirk that he is up to trouble, lol. I think the design is cool, but for my business it might send the wrong message.

#28 I don't think it conveys a strong bold message for our comic book store. It would work well in another industry, but for us the majority of our clients will be male...I want to appeal to women too, but I don't think this logo will capture guys & make them want to wear Shamrock Comics on shirts, etc.

#33 the design looks nice, but it has the look of a button w/the lighting effect

#31 the colors appear too dark, and I think I like something along the lines of the shamrock from #4 or #33 instead...

My wife said that #38 just appears too soft due to the shamrock in the middle.

Love #59! Just not sure about the guy in the middle, it's close but just off...but overall, wow - very cool.

Miamiman, can you take design #59 and make the font and shading the same on Comics below, but keep the size the same...I like how Shamrocks stands out & is larger, but think it might look better w/the same font & shading.

Also, would love to see if you have any other ideas on the character in the middle...but we keep coming back to this overall look - Love it!

#77 we like the look of the plaque holding the comics, but it just appears like something advertising aliens & space.

We like the idea of the irish like superman pose in #96, but the leprechaun just seems to kiddish.