Hi tini1.
I'm sorry you are confused. In my Brief under Style and Concept, I indicated I was looking for Word Marks, Pictorial Marks, Abstract Marks or Characters.
#1 and #2 were pawprints, and several other used a pawprint, but I made no indication that was all I was looking for, I was actually looking for different ideas to choose from. I tried to make some suggestions for your pawprint, but it just wasn't working for me. You had some nice unique ideas in some of your logos such as incorporating the hearts, the dog, cat and bird, and the slogan - we love your pet. Even with your changes, I still liked
#1 and #2 better. I tried to steer you in another direction in hopes that by adding a character, I might like it better and move you to
#1 position. I actually like your designs much better with the name only and no icon or character. I liked the fact that you tried different colours and didn't use the same as everyone else. Thanks for all your hard work. I appreciate your effort.