I've reviewed this contests extensively, and here are what I believe to be the facts:
The concept for the lotus is part of the design brief and open to everyone.
The dispute between Scot & concept_one is regards to the particular style or production of the lotus.
This particular style of lotus could be described as a gradient light coming from the bottom.
Concept_one first entered this particular style in entry #52, #53,
https://logotournament.com/contests/pendalight_productions/by/concept_oneThe earliest use of this style by Scot occurred with entry #280, #281, and #286.
https://logotournament.com/contests/pendalight_productions/by/scotScot's particular issue is that:
#349 by concept_one uses the lotus from his #286.
Concept_one could state that:
#286 borrows from #52, #53, #121, #166, #167, #254
I would like to here from both designers before proceeding.