I think that combback Windsor is GREAT! But the font that I seem to like is all lowercase san-serif. I think the script is too hard to read and looks a little like the Old Spice logo.
Eyecatching, I think we are going with your design as we love the chair the font, etc. However, look at #171 by Brendan. Notice the way his chair is more of a straight on view.
Can you create the logo with the chair more head on like that?