MedallurgyLogo Design Contest

Thank you 'gheist' for this interesting design. I like a lot about it. I particularly like the gold 'shield' and metallic 'M' interacting. I'd like to see the 'shield' have more of a gold metallic look, perhaps 'liquid metal', as one idea to work with. Also, I'd like to see some different fonts with the metallic 'M'. Thanks again... I think this is really cool and look forward to seeing your next design.

thanks for the feedback
v2

(This comment references Entry #22)

alt
v3

(This comment references Entry #23)

Hi. I'm really liking #23. I posted a bunch of feedback on the site, but since this design is high on my list, I wanted to post here too. I'd like to see this one with the text in black and a bit more bold. Thanks!

thanks for the feedback.
revisions as requested plus few tweaks

(This comment references Entry #77)

Regarding #77... I really like this. Can you show me this design, same colors, and font size, only using the more modern font that you used in #23? #77 seems to have a cross bar on the "A", where as #23 does not. This might be because it's there on 23, but not very visible because it's thin. Not sure. Thank you. And please, I do welcome your thoughts on these matters as well. Thanks!

hi rick
here's a variation with reflection.
regarding the A... it's the same font but there are alternate characters
I've shown them all in this variation for your consideration...

(This comment references Entry #78)

Thanks. I like this one a lot. I would prefer the shadow effect of #77 on #78. I think I will be able to use it more readily that way. Thanks. Very good stuff.

Regarding #78.... I definitely prefer the font and letters from #23, and the color and weight of the text of #78. I think this comment and my previous comment capture what I'm after.

Summary... alter #78 by using the shadow effect of #77. Also, use the lettering and font from #23 on #78.

Thanks!

I think that's probably the best combo also
allows it work in 1 color - as shown

(This comment references Entry #102)

Hi. Yes, the 1 color view with #103 works as well. I'm definitely leaning toward #23 as my final choice, but seeing #103 in all black makes me wonder how it would look with the Medal in a 'carbon fiber' look. If you google 'carbon fiber' you can see many examples. Here are a couple links...

http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.benevento4you.com/Images/ColorChartImages/LargeJpegs/SilverCarbonFiber.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.benevento4you.com/ColorChartPopUps/SilverCarbonFiber.html&usg=__kWjZpv6Bgsc9G_D4PS3uRB7f9V4=&h=400&w=400&sz=31&hl=en&start=50&um=1&tbnid=ROL9Uha_h80pwM:&tbnh=124&tbnw=124&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dcarbon%2Bfiber%26start%3D42%26ndsp%3D21%26um%3D1%26hl%3Den%26rlz%3D1B3GGGL_enUS291US291%26sa%3DN

http://www.pdajacket.com/colors/Carbon%20Fiber.jpg

I'm not sure what you can and can't do with photoshop, but the if a 'carbon fiber' look is possible I'd like to see it as an adaptation of #103.

You've got great skill. Thank you for your input.

I can see it getting lost in translation at small sizes...

could look cool as a background though.

I'll give it a shot and see how it goes... straightforward enough to swap it over anyway.

cheers
gheist

hi

carbon fibre as requested

(This comment references Entry #111)

Hi... I am definitely going to with #102, or some variation of it, as my selection. Thanks for your work. I wanted to play with a couple tweeks on the text color. Could you put together a couple examples building on #102 with text color in some blue tones as well as one example with text the same color as #23?

Oh, and thanks for indulging me on the carbon fiber thing. I liked it, but think #102 is the way to go.

Happy that this is going to go your way. You've done nice work. I need a few other photoshopped things put together and would be happy to work with you on them, if you're interested. My email is Rick@Medallurgy.com. Just send me a note and I'll tell you what I'm looking for.

Hi Rick

here's a few options in blue. thanks for the continued positive feedback. will email regarding other work

all the best
gheist

(This comment references Entry #121)

OK I'm definitely going to go with the 'black' text. It just pop's more on my beta web site. One last tweek that I want to try. The proportions on #23 are different than #102. I would like to see design #102 with the text and medal in similar proportions as design #23.

Thanks again.

Rick

sorry my mistake... got moved about somewhere along the way.

these are the correct proportions

(This comment references Entry #126)