GeekSaltLogo Design Contest Logo Design Contest Contests / GeekSalt GeekSalt has selected their winning logo design. For $400 they received 137 designs from 28 different designers from around the world. Find out how LogoTournament works How LogoTournament works Contest Entries by gfdesigns Return to Contest Return to Contest 4th #49 New #99 Withdrawn New #100 New #92 Withdrawn New #39 Withdrawn New #41 Withdrawn Prefers others. #48 Withdrawn Prefers others. #42 Withdrawn Prefers others. #40 Withdrawn Prefers others. #38 Withdrawn Prefers others. #37 Withdrawn Prefers others. #36 Withdrawn Prefers others. #35 Withdrawn Prefers others. #34 Withdrawn Prefers others. #33 Withdrawn Prefers others. #32 Withdrawn Prefers others. #23 Withdrawn Prefers others. #22 Withdrawn Prefers others. #19 Withdrawn Prefers others. #12 Withdrawn Prefers others. #2 Discussion geeksalt Client Looks a bit too much like clip art. 14 years ago geeksalt Client I like this one much better than your previous design, but I'm not sure that the NaCl (which, it is true, is a geeky way of referring to salt) properly conveys the business: experienced website designers who specialise in creating websites for the restaurant industry. 14 years ago geeksalt Client Your character illustration is a lot better than the first logo you submitted. Our only concern is that it might be too detailed to work at small sizes, and that the variation in height might make it difficult to use in a navigation bar. But nice work! 14 years ago geeksalt Client I really like example: #23 - I think the font pops more than in example: #22. At small sizes, though, the salt granules are hard to see. Could you try making them black, and perhaps even experiment with the letter "s" of "salt" being half-formed, with the salt granules being poured out to form the rest?We'd also love to see a few colour variations of example: #23.Great work! 14 years ago gfdesigns Logo Designer Sure, I will be away for some time but will get on that as soon as I can. 14 years ago geeksalt Client Great stuff - I've only kept the design / colour variations that I like the most. I think the salt looks best in example: #33 and example: #35, but I prefer the colour of example: #23 (although perhaps the red of example: #33 would look better if it was lighter, as with other designs we like). Apart from that, I'm not sure which direction we could take this. Perhaps you could do a version of example: #35 with our colour preferences? Any other finessing of the concept you can think of? 14 years ago gfdesigns Logo Designer I reworked the text a little on #40 and #42. 14 years ago geeksalt Client I think I prefer the versions where the s isn't being filled up with salt, but thanks for trying that idea. And we're leaning towards red, but not totally convinced at the moment. I like what you're trying to do with the e's in example: #42, but I think that idea needs to evolve a bit. I don't think the different font in example: #40 works as well. 14 years ago geeksalt Client Unfortunately I don't think the glasses in example: #48 work - a bit too extreme - but swapping colours (so the geek is red) looks nice. 14 years ago gfdesigns Logo Designer I was thinking the same about #48, but I just had to give it a try. 14 years ago gfdesigns Logo Designer I think #49 is better balanced. The boldness of the black balances the brightness of the red. 14 years ago gfdesigns Logo Designer #99 and #100 will work as a favicon without text. 14 years ago geeksalt Client The return of the geek salt shaker - looks good! 14 years ago geeksalt Client Could you do a version of example: #49 with black and red swapped? Like example: #38 but without the black border, which we didn't like. And anything you could do to make the salt granules white instead of black would help :) 14 years ago gfdesigns Logo Designer Sorry, I didn't get this soon enough to make changes. 14 years ago