Kandid,
Response to your design has been very positive. Your first version
#22 is actually the most popular of the one's you've submitted so far. Our focus group just really wants to see this pig "grow up" a few years.
He looks like a little piglet - preschooler piggie and is absolutely adorable and fun, but we really need to choose something that will be appealing to lots of different aged kids - including older boys and grown-ups too. We don't feel like we can put this design as-is on packaging geared toward tweens/teens. Can you see what this pig would look like with a few more birthdays behind him?
We really do love it, the font is awesome, it's bright and colorful. Thank you for your hard work!