Hi Naura,
First, you've earned my ranking as top designer! Congratulations!
I've given you a lot of feedback recently, I hope it's not confusing.
Now I'd like to comment on #233. It seems to have the greatest potential. But first, some background:
- Most of my friends have given higher rankings to designs with some sort of abstract treatment to the 'X'
- I have preferred the 'X' to look somewhat like the font, so that it remains readable.
Focusing on the overall impression of #233:
- Currently, it's too "thin" for me; it should be wider and shorter - a little more masculine - like the font in #188.
- The abstract 'X' will appeal to my friends
- The design captures the essence of the 'curves'
- The design has a hint of the 'fish' symbol used in Christianity, like this:
http://0.tqn.com/d/christianity/1/7/f/2/Christian_Fish.pngI am a Christian, and I prayed that God would give you inspiration in these last minute efforts. I'm happy with the results.
I want to explore the design of the curves; I'd like add more of the Christian fish symbol influence:
- The curves should be elongated to the left and right
- The right end of the curves should terminate at the apex of the arch, like the tail of the Christian fish symbol.
- The left end of the curves should imply that they meet behind the "EMX" text, again, like the Christian fish symbol.
Here's my idea for the letter 'X' within EMXSYS:
- The lower half of the curves are dark or black
- The at the letter X, the curves transition to red
- The upper half curves transition to another color - the highlighted red/yellow perhaps, like in #207.
--- Another color combination for the X is that the 'X' is black and the upper and lower curves are different colors.
What do you think?
Best regards,
-- Bruce