#8 Like it best of the first four submissions The placement of the cross is stronger for our web header we like where you are going with the fonts but they seem unrelated to each other family seems too large in the design we are hoping to have the slogan in the design
#5 Stained glass effect makes it too churchy rigid and formal
#7 Has a good looseness but hoping you can capture some of the spontenaity of gift giving without it being overly casual. Again family seens to large in the design Would need the slogan
These designs seem to focus well on the religious nature of our brand but miss the gift giving nature of our site.