Your designs are fresh...and have a nice zen vibe to them. I like the mermaid "W" in #15 (though I admit i didn't know it was a mermaid until I read your comment)...I would probably opt for the larger wychmere beach club font option in #12 to see if that works with #15
Thanks for the rank and feedback yes the mermaid "W" its too abstract and if you like to move with that idea i can develop it more. anyways ill update you with the modifications you asked
#12 is very fun because I feel the "activities" in this logo. I think the yellow is not our brand though and the splash of color in background wouldn't repro well, but conceptually this is a cool logo; just feels more like a young person beach club vs. a luxury private beach club.
Hey H2...I see you added JAWS with #31 ...lol...or is that a surfboard? Since the 'movie' jaws was filmed just across Nantucket sound, we may want to make it clear which it is. (There were also a dozen great white sightings this summer!). Maybe you want us to guess...??? Either way, very cool!
#30 is growing on me...i think you are going for a 'sand' feel with that font treatment....we'll zero in on either this one or #14 for font refinement...but I need til tomoro! (I really liked the way the W looked like a person in #14 though)....I'd say stick with these colors for sure (versus green/yellow).
I'll re-rank based on your new entries. Stay tuned and Thanks!!!!