We think #8 is a very creative approach. We like how Wally and the ice cream cone are positioned, and the font used for Wicked Good! Wally's eyes are actually chocolate brown--so the blue is a bit startling for us--we'd like to see the color changed. And, the stripe of white down his forehead and nose is a brighter white--we'd like to see that lightened. There are even some wisps of white on the sides of his beard. Lastly, we'd like to see the "ice cream and treats" stand out a little more---perhaps those could be purple? One last thought....we're going for a bit of a magical vibe to play off the wicked (decadent) and good theme. Could the dot over the 'i' be a star or some other element worked in?
Thanks for working with our comments. I'm still looking for a little more white streaking on Wally's face, and if you could make the whites of his eyes a little bigger, that would be great. The star of the "i" looks good, but the swirl of stars around the cone, while creative, gets a little lost. I think I prefer the cone without them.