United RefinishingLogo Design Contest

That's pretty nice looking, but I still have an issue with the alignment.

The star is centered, which is great.

And I like the shape of the shield better, which is also great.

But there's a thin white stripe attached directly above the right arm of the star. So the right arm looks slightly higher and fatter.

You're right, the star wasn't centered in the previous design—my bad! Here's the update.

I really like the italic font of the UNITED.

And the idea of the E flag and the star part of the T was clever. It just doesn't quite work. I don't really have the words to better explain why.

I like it.

I don't know if it's an optical illusion, or if the star is not centered. It looks like it's too far left

Good job. I like the concept, but the execution is a little off.

I like the simplicity.

I don't like how the stripes are different thicknesses, the star is too low in the "D," the left point of the star is higher than the right one. That whole area from the E into the D just has a lot of imperfections.

The whole thing is also just a little too wide and flat for me. If you stretched it a little bit vertically, I'd like the proportions better. That might also allow you to have equal thickness stripes, and give the star inside the D some room to breathe