#1 looking for something more elegant. Too much of a School House Rock feel.

#2 I like the open lime slice
#3 I dig the design, but prefer an easier to read font for "ultimate"

#11 "Ultimate" pops nicely with the box around it but the overall shape of the logo reminds me of a slice of bread. I still prefer your earlier submission, #9. Could you do a #9 with "lime" in black?

#10 I like the font and color used for "Key Lime Pie" but the rest feels a bit too much like "grandma's".

#13 thank you. And a big third day thanks to all of you for your creativity.

#42 #40 I would love to see a version of this with "Key" included on the "Lime Pie" line

#16 #15 #17 I like your use of colors and the background design but the pie graphic isn't clicking.

Thank you again to everyone who has submitted a logo. I presented the top choices to a small group to provide additional feedback and the current favorites are #40 #43 and #7.

#40 As mentioned above, please submit logo with "Key" on the same line as "Lime Pie". This is the only detail preventing a first place ranking right now. Each individual commented on the ability of your logo to catch their eye and draw them in. Very clear and streamlined while containing all of the elements.

#43 Your designs have been consistent favorites during the entire contest and each slight tweak brings the tournament to a new level. Everyone is leaning towards the easy to read fonts. Please keep tweaking.

#7 A favorite from the beginning, your design is in the top for bringing an elegance to the logo accompanied by an all-American ice cream parlor feel. We would love to see some variations of this with larger fonts or something to make the Key Lime Pie aspect jump out a bit more.

Hi Everyone. I'll be getting input from several people today. We will give an updated ranking with additional feedback around 5PM EST. Thanks again.

I've updated the top three ranking based on all of the input.

#51 People who liked this best noted the pie slice itself, the direction it is facing, the lime, leaf, dew drop and back glow. Some commented that "The Ultimate" looks out of place and should be all caps or a different font.

#43 Your presentation of "The Ultimate", your choice of banner and the lime slice background are all favorites. Opinions were split down the middle with the font used for "Key Lime Pie" with half loving it and half thinking it needs to be different.

#46 Your choice of fonts and use of depth and shading stands out above the rest. A circular design seems to be the favorite but behind the triangle on your submission #54 got a few busy comments.