I continue to like number 1 most because it conveys simplicity and the color scheme (black/white with a shot of red) seems to work. I also like the inclusion of the abbreviation LSID and the simple way the full name is displayed on the side without "The" in front. I particularly like that I is part of D and the way the dot on top of I is displayed with a burst of bright color. I also like the shortened on top L. The overall effect of the styling of LSID conveys the idea of a picture, I like this. If this effect is improved further, it would be great. But the logo needs to become more elegant, for example, through better stylization/font of the abbreviation LSID. The lettering in LSID is too fat and clunky, that's why I said it looks sporty.
Number 2 captures the lightness and elegance idea better because the LSID lettering is skinnier and the font conveys lightness, but the overall look is too conservative and it does not add much on number 1.
What is missing from all logos at the moment is more of a spark of originality. The logos at the moment are just a bunch of letters in different combinations.
Blue does not really work. Shades of black, white, a little red, and grey as colors for the concept of LSID seem to work best at the moment. I'd like to see some proposals with other colors as well: let's say deep blue, a faint yellow, the idea of color contrast appeals to me.
Number 3 emphasizes Legal Services from the full name of the company. This effect is achieved through the bigger font size. This is not necessary. All words in the full name of the company are equally important. I ranked this proposal third because it has a little effect under the abbreviation LSID (this little curved line which adds femininity and may be elegance), but it is too common. I have seen it plenty of time before.
Also when one includes the abbreviation LSID, the full name of the company, and the motto "Intelligence for the UK legal sector", the whole thing appears too wordy and not like a logo, but a mouthful.
Interestingly, when LSID letters are colored in white, the overall effect is one of lightness. Especially if combined with skinnier, stylized letters. I'd love to see a few proposals in this vein please.
I like the word intelligence. This is what the company is selling.
.