The Garden City Rink Rats Ice Hockey ClubLogo Design Contest

Logo Design Contest
Contests / The Garden City Rink Rats Ice Hockey Club

The Garden City Rink Rats Ice Hockey Club has selected their winning logo design.

For $575 they received 75 designs from 13 different designers from around the world.
2nd
#72

Withdrawn

4th
#23

Withdrawn

5th
#50

Withdrawn

New
#69

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#71

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#70

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#68

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#67

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#52

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#51

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#49

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#48

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#47

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#26

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#25

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#24

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#22

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#21

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#8

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#7

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#6

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#5

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#3

Discussion

 
Client
Hi bikinSendiri.

Good start.

Can you add a white or silver outline to the outside of the badge - the logo needs to work on the dark blue of the home jersey as well as the white of the away jersey.

Can you add some 'hockey tape effect' to the hockey sticks - they look a little like golf clubs at the moment.

Thanks
Stan
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Thank you Mr. Stan,
Will update as requested and upload by tonight jakarta time

Best Regards
Medi
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Question Mr. Stan,
RATS only or RINK RATS?
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Update: #5 #6 #7 #8
13 years ago
 
Client
Hi again.

Yep - RINK RATS should be the hero text.

Entry #6 - can you change the puck image? - that looks a little more like a yo-yo or something. A puck is a solid round block of rubber.

Entry #8 - the circle doesn't work for me as a logo - the shield concept is much better.

Thanks.
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Good Morning Mr Stan,
Sure, i will revise the puck and update by tonight Jakarta time.
Feel free if you need anything else to revis my entries

Best Regards
Medi
13 years ago
 
Client
Hi again.

I like #7 as a secondary image. Can you turn the hockey sticks up the other way? - it might make a nice shoulder patch to contrast the main logo on the chest / front.

Perhaps also reverse the colour format - so dark blue inside the shield, light blue outside?

Cheers.
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Sure:) i will send the updates in couple hours
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
update: #21 #22 and #23 #24
new option: #25
13 years ago
 
Client
Morning - #25 is too similar to an existing hockey team that plays here in our local market, so no good I'm sorry.

Other designs are good - i've kept the one's that are heading in the right direction and discarded the others.

The puck is still not quite correct - I'll look around and see if I can find a better example.

Thanks.
13 years ago
 
Client
#26 - can we add a big more shading to the image? the grey shading in #23 gives the Rat good shape.

And can you try something with the mouth? perhaps a tooth poking through? Eyes are good, nose is good, whiskers are good - I think it just needs something different around the mouth...

And can you add the tail swirl from #23?

Thanks again.
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Hello again Mr. Stan,
Thank you, glad you like them:), no worry about 25, i just try for another option.
i will prepare for another changes and update by tonight jakarta time

Regards
Medi
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
update: #47
13 years ago
 
Client
That's great Medi.

#47 - it's a very minor point, but we haven't got it quite right yet for the puck 100%.

Can you make it more 3-D - I suggest add some grey highlights to the surface of the puck or a highlight to the leading edge of the puck.

Maybe even give the puck motion and bring it bursting out of the shield?

It may be too subtle for the embroidered image (I'll make it simpler if that's the case), but as I'm also using this artwork for a web page - this little big of detail might be very nice.

Perhaps surf the web with the keyword puck and have a look at some ideas.

#22 - can you then add this updated puck artwork to this design please.

Thanks again.
Stan.
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
I will keep trying for the puck,
about using on shirt and on website: how if there will be 2 versions of the logo, one with limited colors and less detail for the shirt and the other one with gradient effect and hi details..might be a bit different between them but it will be just the finishing effect.

i also will update the #22's puck.
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
update for puck 47: #48 #49
update 22: #50
13 years ago
 
Client
That sounds great Medi.

Yes - let's have 2 versions as suggested.

I'm liking #50 as the shoulder patch version.

Cheers.
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Mr.Stan,
It's very busy day to me out there, and it's 3 am now here in Jakarta,
i need some rest and will be back to you with the 2nd version options by this day.:) is that ok?

Best Regards
Medi
13 years ago
 
Client
Yep. Thanks.
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Good Day Mr. Stan
1st try for gradient effect was #52,
feel free if you have any suggestion

:)
Medi
13 years ago
 
Client
Hi again Medi,

I think I like #48 better at this point - the balance of white and blue look sharper than the grey.

If you added more colors to #52 to make the image look bettered and with more impact (so we would use this version of the logo on the web page) - what would you suggest? Be creative.

Thanks
Stan.
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Well Mr. Stan, i have some options in my mind, i will do exercise first and then upload them a.s.a.p

13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Good Evening Mr. Stan,
i made some update, please check: #67 #68 #70
13 years ago
 
Client
Excellent - #68 looks the best I think, the others are dark because of the blue & grey combination.

Thanks Medi.
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
You are welcome Mr. Stan,
Let me know if you need something else
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
how about these ones: #70 #71
13 years ago
 
Logo Designer
mean: #71 #72
13 years ago
 
Client
Hi again Medi.

I wanted to thank you once again for your hard work - I appreciate your level of responsiviness in making alterations and following my suggestions.

Pleasure to have had you working on our logo.

I'm sorry to say that we can only pick one - and we went with the other designer mainly because the rat-man image got better feedback from our players.

But it was this close...!

Thanks again - and good luck with your other competitions.

Keep an eye out for my contests - I have another running currently which is a bit simpler in concept than this sports logo. Would like to see your ideas on that one.

Cheers.
Stan.
13 years ago
Login
Home Start on your logo Contests Portfolio Designers Why? Help Contact Us
Forum About Us
1-800-300-3231