Regarding #11 and #12 - I like the font in both. I like #12 option more because the word bubble treatment. I am thinking of using a white background - can you explore #12 with a white background.
I am looking for a symbolic connection to sports stats or youth sports.I looked at your profile and I am drawn to your plastic rewards and playgrid logos. I keep stats for various sports on stats sheets - the marks on these brands could inspire a thought in that direction.