Ok, as we are approaching the last 24 hours, I would like to give a short resume:
As you see in the ranking, we like the logos with a graphical element, which includes an “S” representing the selection we do on the site. The “4” is misleading for what we try to do and so it should not compare in the graphical element, only in the word mark. The “S” instead should be clearly recognizable and therefore be visible with a good contrast. Also the check in the graphical element is a good idea.
Some more details:
We like the graphical Symbol in #73, but the text is better in #171 and #191. Especially the color combination in #191 is very good (blue and a bright orange), the “4” is very elegant, but we had the response, that it is not clearly visible as it, but could be seen as the “red aids ribbon”. But it remains one of our favourites.
#171 and #170 are nice, but are missing some contrast in the graphical element, maybe also a third color (orange?) could be nice.
#160 has the graphical element, that should be an S, but is also hardly recognizable,
Same for #165.
#164 is also very nice as word mark, clean and elegant, but it has the “4” in the graphical element instead of the “S” and/or the check. The upper case letters are also difficult to read, compared to some others.
Also #17 is very nice and has good colors, but we experienced, people see a plane instead of the “4” and failed to read the name.
Finally regarding the colors: we like the bright blue and orange of #191, we also like the green of #50
Cheers and thank you all again for your great submissions