These are both really on the right track. I like the font you used in entry #7 for "s'more." Can we maybe add just a bit more to the overall design without losing the rustic/old world feel you've created? Maybe a muted color in the background (pale peach or something).
I also have an image that I'd like you to look at. It's the header for my blog Ode to Sugar. Check it out at odetosugar.blogspot.com--it has the muted color palette that I like but maintains some edge. Essentially, I like the combination of faded/vintage photographs coupled with more edgy, darker prints.
The one with the peach background is my favorite so far, but I'm not crazy about the sharp edges of the border. Is there a way to make it more ethereal and softer and not such a rigid outline? I'm also curious to see if you can find another similar kind of graphic for the logo--it doesn't have to be a s'more per se; it could be a graphic image of a marshmallow on a skewer, etc.
Wow, what happened to the other designer? I stopped working on mine because his/hers was too good. I know I can improve on what I have here. Let me go to work on it~ Love your feedback!