Rockhopper MediaLogo Design Contest

Great job on the penguin hair! Can you do #11 without the place marker for the letter O and also differentiate the luggage so it doesn't look like part of the penguin - like you had in #7. Thanks.

Hi darodi,

Thanks for your feedback and rank, here is the revision you asked #19, please let me know what you think.

-Edwin

Can i see #19 without the luggage but the same otherwise?

Of course, did you mean like this #43 ?

Thanks,
Edwin

Hi darodi,

Can I ask you what make you change your mind? or may be you have any feedback so I can improve my design?

Thanks,
Edwin

We're thinking #43 just doesn't work without the luggage. Yet #19 is looking a bit too cartoony. It's fun and on-brief, but not as clean and professionally toned as we're looking for.

Hi Darodi, thanks for your explanation, now I know what is wrong with my design, I wish that explanation about how too cartoony my design I could got at open phase so I can do the revision for you.

Or could you please give me a chance to do the revision? I could do the professional toned instead cartoony one for you. Right now your contest is in "judging" phase, which mean only the first rank designer can still submit new design or revision. If you willing to give me a chance to submit a new revision please put me at the first rank again so I can see my submit button again.

And please note that you can always change or switch the rank whenever you want.

Thanks,
Edwin

I've put you back in 1st, thanks.

Thanks a lot, please keep it for a while, I'll do the design right now and submit it ASAP.

Thanks,
Edwin

Hi darodi, here they are #53 and #54 more clean and professional tone than the previous, please let me know your feedback on these.

Thanks,
Edwin

And this more simple and clear #55

#54 is okay, although it's a bit plain and looks like he's carrying a briefcase. But the others, like the ones with the suitcase, look a little like a grumpy penguin in my opinion, not a very 'fun' or positive image. That's why I liked #36...definitely has a fun, positive vibe to it, at least how I see it.

Thanks, I'll try something to bring the positive feel and fun aspect to my design, please wait for my next revision.

Thanks,
Edwin

Hi Darodi,

I already submit my new design, here it is #57, what do you think?

Thanks,
Edwin

Hi,

Did you want me to do any revision? or you already set your choice with your current first rank design?

Thanks,
Edwin

We are leaning towards the option that is in first place but have delayed our decision by two weeks before we decide. If you'd like to make more options I will place you in first place so that you can submit. Just let me know.

Yes of course, please, I'll try my best.

I've put you in first.