#4: It's the only round one so I want to keep it to think about it but I definitely don't like the middle map icon. Too busy. A solid shape would be better. Or a simpler design in that part.
Same comment as #4 about that shape treatment. I like the idea of a unique shape that can be used independently but this one is too complicated. I am keeping it for now to think through the difference (and inclusion) of the "for victory" portion in the logo.
Dear Ketut, Of all the designs you submitted we came down to 3 similar ones. I would like to see the concepts of the 3 merged into a final thought. 1) Kill the "for victory", 2) do not have a letter inside the map icon so that if we want to use just the map portion as a small icon it can stand on its own, 3) Try to balance the words Ramapo and United. The one with United being larger is good but its too much larger. Thank you for all the thought you put into these.