Pie Plant PieLogo Design Contest

If you need it...you can have a variation of logo then...i will separetly send to you via email. you can give me your email addresss via PM.Thanks

I like #207 but I also think it is necessary to have #208 since I’ll be making a simple stamp to use and the shadowing will be too much. Do people often work with the designer for more than 1 variation?

Yes, I agree with you, thanks for your input.

& #200 more centered compotition

In my opinion #207 is look more clean/light than #200

I'm having a really hard time choosing between #207 and #200.
I know there are subtle differences between the placement of the 3 vents. I go from liking one more than the other and then back again.
#207 is nice because there is a look of action around the P.
#200 is nice because fills the space around both words....

Do you have any comments from a designer point of view?

Yes, thank you!!

did you mean like this one? version black & white of #202

Strange, I received an email notification that you sent me the b&w version of this but it’s not showing up here. Could you please resend? Thank you.

do you want this #202 on black & white version?

Ok, I think I’m close. Only one left that’s missing before I can do a full side by side is this one with no shadow and no color in the crust. The Pie is smaller in this one. Thanks.

The version of #203 with the gold color in the crust and no shadow on the letters

hi...The version 0f #203 with letters shadowed in gold and gold in the crust

I also like the positioning of everything here.
~Both words are the same font size
~I like the positioning of the half circle border
~I like where the 3 lines (the vents are positioned)

Could I see the other 2 versions with this same positioning and font size here?
~The version with letters shadowed in gold and gold in the crust
~The version with the gold color in the crust and no shadow on the letters

Thanks

Hi...without font shadow version...thanks

Sorry, I should have said, the b&w version that is not shadowed letters. Can you do that version too? Thank you.

this is The version with unshadowed letters the gold color in the crust of #200

Hi...this is black & white version of #200

UPDATE!!

HI there, I like the positioning of everything here.
~Both words are the same font size
~I like the positioning of the half circle border
~I like where the 3 lines (the vents are positioned)

Could I see the other 2 version with this same positioning and font size here?
~The all black and white version
~The version with unshadowed letters the gold color in the crust

Thanks,
Erika

HI there, I like the positioning of everything here.
~Both words are the same font size
~I like the positioning of the half circle border
~I like where the 3 lines (the vents are positioned)

Could I see the other 2 version with this same positioning and font size here?
~The version with letters
~The version with the color in the crust

Thanks,
Erika

Can you keep the size of Pie, don’t change it,, just the position of the half circle. Can you try it with #155 too?

Can we move the half circle a little, just like the new one?

You can keep the size of Pie, don’t change it on this one, just the position of the half circle.

bring the half circle back a little

Can you bring the half circle back a little, right in between where it is here and where it was before?

I see that making Pie the same size does change the visual quite a bit with the 3 lines.

If you shift the inner half circle a bit clockwise, maybe that would change things? Can you try a few versions of that? Thanks.

Hi. The remaining 4 ranked logos are the ones I like. Im having a hard time choosing the final one that I like.

Can you make the word Pie the same size as plant please? I’d like to see how that looks on the 4 logos. It looks like #155 already has Pie the same size. Thanks.

This would be a good one to have - black and white - for a stamp - and there is now shadow.

I like how this image is a little tighter on top with the smaller font in Pie and it just seems more balanced. Can this be done with both words the same size?

I guess you'd have to shift the 3 vents down a bit to fill the space above the P in Plant?

HI there, can I see the font here shadowed and inside creases in gold as in #164? Trying to see the difference in the size of Pie - the word, as it's bigger here.

I do think that they should be the same size since Plant shouldn't really have more weight than Pie since it's not the priority - they should be the same. But I do see in #152 (and if it were shadowed in gold) that design-wise it is a little less clunky. It's very subtle. What do you think?

And this version, the Pie is smaller. I know you explained it to me why. Can you again? Just wondering.

Yes...to make it balance

I see, the 3 vents are gold too. Nice touch, thanks!

I’m still not sure about no black in the logo. Thanks!

hi,trying color option here

hi,trying color option here

I guess this could work. Not sure people will get it. But again, I like the addiction of a second color. I like it the more I look at it. Can you offer your opinion?

back to golden colour

back to golden colour

Sorry if I wasn’t clear. Can you make a change in this version and the #188 - keep the letter shadows green but change the outer crust edges that golden yellow? Thanks!

This one too please!

Thanks, could you keep the green in both of these versions but make the pie crust the golden color you had before?

Hi, on #174 , #159 & #177 "pie" smaller than "Plant"
on #155 , #178 & #152 "pie" is same size with "Plant".
Which one do you prefer? same or different size? thanks

more lighten green here

Hi, changing colour to green

I'd still like to see if you can replace the word shadowing on this version with a green of some sort, something that could distinguish a plant, but not too bright. Thanks!

Hi there, I just noticed that the top 6 logos that you created, some of the word Pie are smaller than Plant. Do you see this? Can you explain what the difference is?
Thanks

Ok, I have a cool idea, can you replace the word shadowing on this version with a green? Not too bright.

OK, thanks

That is nice. Can you add these additional 3 lines in versions #155, #159, and #152 also?

:) will reduce it bit more

Thanks, the veins in the plant creep me out a little :)

adding a rhubarb leaf under Pie Plant, thanks

I like this a lot. In your opinion, is there too much white space underneath Plant? If there is a simple reference or graphic/style similar to this retro design of a rhubarb leaf that can go there?

just remove the second word pie on #164

Ok, this is nice. Can you please remove the second word pie and keep everything else as is?
Thanks,

Will work on this and submit it soon,thanks

I actually love this. Please:

1 -remove second pie
2 -remove brown shadow on pie plant

Thanks!

Sorry, that was confusing. I was curious to see “Pie Plant” and no second word pie in the solid font that you used in the other examples - the second word PIE.

do you mean using font on #138 ?

Could you try this wording that’s the solid font used for the second word Pie that’s in the original?

Pie Plant on the same size, and back to BW

Yes, I see what you mean. This is probably better as a black & white logo.

Going back to b&w, could you try making pie plant the same size and remove the second word pie?

Hi...i'm trying adding some colour on #150 & #151 , i think is working...but not as simple as one color...How about you?

I like this one out of the new ones, thanks. Maybe the leaf concept is too much.

I took a look at your other logic you’ve created. From a designer standpoint, if you were to add color, what would you do? I don’t think too many different colors, maybe the pie, or the outline, lettering?

i will try with another option & ideas then, thanks

Ok, I didn’t e en think I was trying to do that. This is my first time with this. Now that I’m in the second phase of the contest, I’m not really 100% as to what’s supposed to happen next.

I’m trying to see options with & without the 2nd word pie.

I’d like to see the rhubarb image in and not. Same with the pie image.

I’m curious as to different fonts as well.

I like your design sense and would like to see some other ideas if you have them. Thank you!

Hi,i'm sorry, i think i cant do that ( the leaf coming out of the top part of the inner line of the thicker circle ), since it will be similar with other contestant entries. Thanks

Can you remove the second word pie and also have the leaf coming out of the top part of the inner line of the thicker circle? As if that were the stem?

I’d like to see the stem & leaf more flowing and no so rigid. Maybe the font she change for that to happen?

Yes. But I think that leaf is too dark?

Hi...did you mean like this one?

Hi there. Could you make the second word Pie plural- just to see what it would look like?
Then, where the 3 slots are on the top left, could make a rhubarb leaf and stem instead?
Thanks

This is nice too. Simple. I think the pie concept with a go with different fonts and with and without Pie on the bottom is getting close to my vision.

Nice. Retro. Do you think you can streamline it? Simplify somewhat?

This is nice. Can you try some other fonts? Old fashioned but kind of modern and bold. Like what you’d see on the side of a 50’s pie delivery van

Thank you!!!

i Will trying another entries soon...thanks

Maybe keep the three lines inside the pie on the top and remove the bottom 3?

Yes. Still seeing too many lines inside the pie and too much white space tho. What do you think?

like this one?

I like the inner crust like before. Can you bring that back and stack the first word?

Could you position the first word Pie on top and off the right of the word Plant?

But I like them in the pie too, just too much! Ah!

The lines are nice in the crust.

There are a lot of lines in the crust, and then the lines in the pie... overkill?

But the crust shadow is nice.

Hmm, I think the graphic overpowers the words a bit. Any ideas?

But yes, I see the second word pie smaller. This is the idea. Thanks!

Do you think there’s too much white space?
I also commented on another version of the crust that I really liked. Do you see it?

Hi, how about this one?

I like this crust, it’s nice!!

These are both nice too, without the leaf. Sorry, I commented before I saw these. Pie Pant is the main theme and then the last pie is a separate thought. Im also worried that there’s 2 words pie and a picture of a pie but when the second word pie is not there it seems to make a difference. Do you like the 2 words there? Maybe the second word pie should be a little different, maybe on its own?

This is nice too. Same, take the leaf away? It’s kind of fluttery.

Hi, looks nice, I like pie image. Could you take the leaf away and make the last word pie smaller or a different font?

Thanks for your submission. It’s a bit dark. I think it would be easy for the rhubarb to be lost. Can you made it more black & white and more geometric? Font is good. Thanks!