HI LG Thanks so much for the revisions and i understand what you have said above - I do not want you to break any rules of the LT!!
Yes i can extract the icon myself so that is well understood
#39 is the "one" its the best of them all
#52 now has the shading perfect but the overall look of #40. #52 the lines are too broken - for example - - - - - -
#51 also has the shading perfect but again #41 is still better because the lines are not too broken (- - - - -) and i like the bits of blue colour that is visible in #41.
So to round it all off, once we name you the winner would you be able to send us
#39, #40 and #41 and we could change the shading ourselves to look like #51 and #52 or would you be prepared to do redo #51 and #52 for us and then us the 5 files????
Thank you so much for working with us - we will announce the winner officially tonight Australia time!!