P2P MagazineLogo Design Contest

(It's still early to rank entries but not too early to give tips what i'm searching.) Update, first ranking done.

First of all, thanks for your entry, they are all beautiful. And now the tips.

#2 #3 #4 Nice entries and original. But i'm searching a logo more large, that can fit well if a choose a logo dimension of 559x111 pixel (approximation), better a logo with a mascot. My opinion is that the moust beautiful between #2 #3 #4 is logo #2, maybe with other characters for the word magazine

#1 Commented.

#5 A beautiful logo but it's not what i'm searching. It's the "standard" logo but nothing distinctive that can "say to the reader" whow i'm reading a online magazine. Same words of #2 #3 #4, i', searching (if possibile) a mascot.

More Feedback:
If you need more info, my idea is a logo colourful with a p2p mascot like https://logotournament.com/contests/central_carolina_boat_fishing_expo naturally for another kind of audience like p2p users and filesharing users of a online magazine or https://logotournament.com/contests/earthquake_lacrosse/by/thecreech
naturally tech related and p2p related for a tech magazine.

Another possible solution is something like https://logotournament.com/contests/college_football_geek/by/gonorth
- Entry #28 with a slogan "File sharing is not a crime !" and naturally with a design tech - filesharing related

Here is the layout of the new site (work in progress but done 90%):
http://img41.imageshack.us/img41/4816/layoutp2pmagazine.jpg

Please take a moment to read this "Ranking and General Tips" as complied by one of our designers (Bugy) https://logotournament.com/forum/general_discussion/914

Scott
EastCoast Creative
Designer/LT Moderator

Thanks for suggestion but i know this tips, i used a few months ago logotournament for another logo and i was very satisfied, a lot of talented designers. If you refer about my tips they are obvious not a "clone intention", they are normal tips because we're searching something different from the 5 logos that designer has done despite they are all beautiful.

I mean i'm searching a logo that is wide and can fit well if i choose a logo dimension of 470x100 for example.
For reference here is layout of the new site, this is why i'm searching a logo whith a white background:

http://img41.imageshack.us/img41/4816/layoutp2pmagazine.jpg

(<deleted> - Thanks for all for submissions. Never seen so much talented designers like now in a single place. I always have an idea from yesterday of final logo and i think it's irresponsible to leave contest open if i have the final idea for the logo because to realize a logo is time expensive. I've done a final ranking and i don't know how to thanks everyone for participation.
I leave contest open still a few hours, this is the minimum i can do so if you hav final idea you can present it.
Still thanks everyone.</deleted>)
Update, contest still open, excuse me for previous message but since i still see interesting ideas, forget what i wrote before

Thanks everyone for your entry, they were all beautiful. This time i was very "struggle" in the middle of the first 3 entries but it doesn't mean that other entries were horrible, they were always beautiful entries from excellent designers but i think "distant" from my personal idea.
I decide this time to really close Contest since i have finally the idea for the final logo.
Thanks and still thanks everyone.

Thanks and congratulations Immo0~!