That first one was a flat-color grunge version, which is what you could put on t-shirts and whatnot. Here is a more touched up full-color version for all other uses: #11.
Also, the grunge texture is on its own layer, so we can turn it on or off as needed, depending on the application or look you want...
I like these. Definitely the right direction. What would the grunge version look like if we masked out the cards so that they weren't part of the grunge layer?
Nice idea. Here it is: #12. I like that the cards stay legible and pop a little more. Good call for sure...
I will be signing off for the night soon, but I will be around tomorrow morning with additional ideas/variations. Feel free to leave any other thoughts or requests in the meantime.
Here is the top-ranked design on a white/transparent background, #44... As you can see, it still works well with the border and shadow. Let me know if you happen to think of anything else you might want to see. I am sure you are busy with the holidays and whatnot, so no rush!