The little 8-bit pizza icon could be its own standalone logo—the main defining mark of your brand. Let me know if you dig the 8-bit approach or not, as I love how it ties into the old school arcade feel.
I like the arcade/Atari feel of the icon. That is a really good idea. I have some partners that I need to get with and get there feelings about what they think. I thnik a vintage look is something we were considering from the start.
I like the cursive writing on entry #18. We might like to do a design like that in neon. Want it to have a retro feel. Neon, lightbulbs etc.... This kind of design would also look good on a t-shirt.
I like the way you are going with it. The est. 2012 may need to be on the bottom......or bottom slightly right. Looking at the slice of pizza.....not sure......
On the designs such as entry#18, 25, and 26, can you try replacing the 8-bit pizza with a regular slice of pizza to get an idea of what that might look like.
No problem. I should be able to get to that later today/tonight. I will be gone most of the day, but this will be my top priority when I return. Talk with you then!