Hi Verheven,
We really like #45 with the 'shine'.
Because this logo will be sitting on the front cover it would be good to see the logo on a solid background so that it can be placed on the magazine without photo show-through.
Also, will the colours be easy to change using Illustrator/Indesign - even with the shine? I am a basic user of the Adobe suite of tools (I'm a mag editor rather than designer, but will need to be both for the launch!).
Thanks,
Bec & Dave