I'm fond of #192 and how the door comes across with the 'home-grown' feel. Would it be possible to apply the same 'broken-edges' look to the text of Locals' Door? Please play with it and see what you can come up with.
In addition, could you try and integrate Locals' Door with the physical door? I like how you textured the door - could you maybe turn the top right rectangle into the L in Locals' and the bottom right rectangle into the D for Door? See what you can come up with, I'm excited to see if what I have in my head can come to life.
Also: the lack of a door knob really stands out in my mind as possibly good or bad. In your future designs could you create copies with and without a doorknob? Or keyhole even - something to give the impression that you are welcome.