Great job so far! #1 is the preference, would like to see what it would look like in a flatter design. For the streaks behind the skate, it would be nice to see the top 3 removed and only the bottom one left. What would the logo look like on a white background?
One more note, stretching the "Skate Sharpening & Pro Shop" to the full length of "Liam's" might help as well. We do not want that to get lost by being too small.
#18 - still looking for a flatter effect, no gradients. The logo has a bit of a feminine feel to it. Looking for a bit more masculine and sporty. Some blacks introduced into the logo may help. Potentially another angle of the skate might work better as it has a bit of the appearance of a figure skate up on its pick.