The cookie is way too specific. Let's leave off any kind of pastry all together. The style of the type face should exude the quality portion of our messaging but I do like the use of the leaf. Also leaning towards script type face and not the serif type you've done here.
Definitely closer with #2! The script is nice, the tea leaf may be a little too simple. Would like to see slightly more intricacy there and perhaps even on the script.