Okay, the good and the bad - when the logos were ranked, many commented that they liked the feel of #17, but still were worried that without the "house" involved, it wouldn't lend itself to cross-branding our properties. One person said, "what happens if the circle that the letter "i" is in were morphed into a house? Not something blocky, but round and with the gradient like the circle has? Almost like you stretch the circle into a house (yeah, I know, I thought that sounded odd, too).
Does that make sense? Basically, the feedback is, "I really like the feel, but really wish we could keep the concept of the "i" being in a house..."