I actually like the feel of this one. It reminds me of an logo like the Columbian Coffee guy or Mr. Clean. Can you do some tweeking.
1) No need to have a sprayer or gloves. 2) Perhaps zoom in closer on the man's face and shoulders. 3) How about pinstripes like a zoot suit. 4) Do some adjustments with the fonts and the rectangle to see what you can do to make it more interesting. 5) There's something just a little off with the hat.
Ok, I like the mafia man but the overall logo is just kind of boring. I want a logo that's catchy and attractive and represents my company. I mentioned previously that I like nostalgiac logos that you might see on a tin sign.
So, This is my thought. A circle with a banner across it at an angle. 'Godfather' written in a script-like font (still clearly readable though). 'Pest Control, Inc.' arched along the bottom and the top of the circle above the banner would be the mafia man with his hat pulled down over one eye at an angle because the banner is at an angle. A lot of baseball logos are kind of like this.