The colors and pixellated "funky" font are great. The "rustic" font is too graffiti / urban, and instead of paint the background would better be wood or stone (though that is harder to pull off in vector).
Thanks for the wood background, however the outline still indicates that it is wet paint. How about a piece of raw wood with tree grain texture?
You're right about #16 being in first. We requested funky, rustic but also professional. Those things don't really work well together, but 16 got "funk" with the jumbled letters and had a very clever use of the tuning fork, so it ends up looking slick, but definitely not that funky or rustic.