We like the look of the text in #14 and #15 and how the igloo sort of interacts with the text, but we're concerned that the igloo itself looks "run down" and damaged. Generally though quite a nice piece.
#18 looks really great! The feedback we've been giving to other artists is to try to make the igloo look a little more cozy. Also, rather than a completly blue background what about surrounding the logo in blue but have a white background? I think the black might be a little too harsh and not quite "cozy" enough.
We're not really liking the placement of "college". Also the igloo could look a little more "cozy" and a little more identifiable as an igloo (perhaps more 3D and/or rotate to the side a little?).
Just brainstorming with you and don't want to direct your creative process too much, but a possibility might be to either add the text "college" under the igloo in #21 or perhaps place it on top of the "i" and "l" sort of like a lid similar to how the igloo sits on top in #18.
Thanks for the feedback. I'm glad you like new proposals. Please confirm that the layout idea ("college" under the igloo) is yours and didn't came from another designer, and I'll make requested changes right away. This is one of the rules here, on logotournament. Thanks for understanding!
requested revisions. I I've got the confirmation from the other designer. Sorry for the inconvenience. If you'd like to see any additional changes, just let me know. Thanks!