I really liked the addition of colors to the fish in both entries #25 and 24. If possible, can I see #25 without the catch it? Also, I was wondering what both of these logos would look if you maintained the fish colors but had the wording setup in a more monochromatic fashion. Maybe using shades of gray / graphite (even possibly shading in the white area within the letters as well).
I really like logo 58 but I think I can live without the sports & recreation and it needs a .com. If you could make it look more like logo 57 with the same font but the metallic look to the letters that would be really great. I think that's pretty much it.