Hi White Splash! Thanks for your entries.
I love that you added the check & X icons (clearly you checked out my site, thanks!!)... but I feel like those are a little too dramatic or obvious. Additionally, I'm not really doing as many of my "Menu Mondays" posts anymore, so I'd rather not emphasis the "eat this not that" part of the site. Having said that, aesthetically, #17 is my favorite of that concept series.
I also like the exclamation mark idea -- often when I tell people the name of my site, I try to emphasize the play on words (three-eating-rules, vs, eating-is-awesome), and the exclamation mark helps that. Of these, I'd probably choose #25 or #21... putting the exclamation mark inside the "eating" (#20 and #23) is a little too distracting for me.
I'd love to see you explore #25 a little more, and see if you can find a way to help indicate that my site is about healthy food, both the "rules" and the "fun" parts. :)
Thanks!