Our Ideas and Additional Information:
Thinking the "DS" initials can be incorporated into a symbol or design that is created, so it can stand alone if needed without the full site name (for example, in a circle so we can use it as a social media profile pic).
And though it's a Christian theme, we'd like to avoid having Christian imagery (i.e. cross)
Update: Here's the new theme we'll be using for the site, would like something that matches the feel: http://dspirituality4.staging.wpengine.com/