Hi Dustin,
I've sent the contest out to a few friends / clients and colleagues to ask their opinions.
#125 is getting the best response.
There's one issue that won't work about it - which is the color. It's almost identical to my biggest competitor's color scheme :) I like it, in that it would work well on black or white. I like that it's not overly bold. I like that it's not pink! I'm not sure what the 'right' color is ... but would be interested in seeing a couple of options.
One bride who also does some graphic design chose
#125 as her favourite - but gave the feedback below. I think she makes some great points and I'd be keen to see some variations based on her feedback too:
So in saying all of that…if I had to pick one from this bunch…I would pick
#125. It is simple…attractive…the logo alone can also be used as a sort of company branding like Channel or Motorola like you stated in the brief and it will transform into black and white very easily. Although, I will admit that even though I think it is the only stand out, out of all the designs on there, there still seems something not right about it. Maybe see if you can see the logo with ‘wedding films’ in a different font from what he has used for the D’nM part…a font that is sans serif maybe? So more of an Arial type font rather then a Times New Roman type font. If you look at
#175…see if you can use the font in that design but on the ‘wedding films’ in
#125…it may make it look boring but it may have the opposite effect and add depth…but its worth a look. Also…the ‘wedding films’ in
#125 seems a like bit like random placement…as though its there only because it has to be…the logo over all is stronger without it there..so see if he can maybe marry them somehow (excuse the pun! Ha) so maybe dragging it up to overlap into the circle but have it more off to the right then in the centre and where the same colours overlaps… reverse the colour…so if the white is on top of white…have the top white in the aqua colour…if that makes sense?