CookadillyLogo Design Contest

Logo Design Contest
Contests / Cookadilly

Cookadilly has selected their winning logo design.

For $375 they received 144 designs from 36 different designers from around the world.
1st
#133

Withdrawn

New
#36
Prefers others.
#96
Prefers others.
#95
Prefers others.
#54

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#53
Prefers others.
#52
Prefers others.
#51
Prefers others.
#40

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#39
Prefers others.
#38
Prefers others.
#37

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#35

Discussion

 
Logo Designer
#35, #37, #38

Hi,

Please let me know if you'd like any revisions. i'd be happy to provide them. Thanks!

Pam
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
#39 & #40

Variations. Let me know if you'd like different fonts, colors, etc. Or if you'd like to mix and match elements from one design with elements of another. Thanks!
11 years ago
 
Client
These are nice! Let me get some feedback for you!!!
11 years ago
 
Client
Let's go with #37 but with these edits:

substitute the pan flourish (the eyelash-like treatment) from #39
try one with #cookadilly below the logo (maybe on right-hand side?) < - I want to promote the site via hashtags
add the slogan "good food, plain and simple"

Thank you!!!
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Thanks for the feedback! Here are the revisions you requested:

#51 - substituted the flourishes from #39 onto #37

#52 - added the slogan

#53 - added the hashtag and the slogan (I placed the hashtag above the logo, because it was too conflicting when placed below with the slogan)

#54 - hashtag only beneath the logo

Let me know if I correctly understood what you were requesting. Feel free to ask for changes on these.

Thanks!

Pam
11 years ago
 
Client
Hey Pam!

Thanks for these great designs. This is tough. It's now down to 2 designers so give this one last round of effort.

Please make one more round of decision edits to #133:

sub tagline to "a food lover's playground"
try subbing an orange for the "a" in cookadilly and then changing up the "cook" or "dilly" so one of them is more neutral. My only challenge with the logo is the colors... I want a slightly more modern feel (without losing the whimsy that you have created!).'

Also, is it acceptable to ask for a logo with and without the steam flourish? So I could choose which one to use depending on the medium (print versus Website, for example).

THanks tons, Pam!!!

Thanks,

Jackie
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Hi Jackie,

I will gladly make your requested revisions. However, since your contest is now in Judging mode, I cannot submit any entries. Only the 1st ranked person can submit during Judging mode.

If you want to see my revisions, or revisions from any other designers not ranked first, you must place me/them in first so we can submit.

Yes, you can have the logo both ways. No problem with that.

Lastly, can you clarify "subbing an orange for the 'a' in cockadilly". Do you mean the fruit or the color? I'm assuming you mean the color, but since you said "an orange" I wanted to be sure. :)

Thanks!

Pam



11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Hi Jackie,

I have a revisions ready to upload, but cannot since I'm not ranked in 1st place. Reranking would allow me to upload so you can make your decision.

Remember: Contest guidelines stipulate that only the first place designer can upload during the judging phase.

Pam
11 years ago
 
Client
Hi again, Pam:

Please make one more round of decision edits to #133:

sub current tagline to "a food lover's hangout"
try subbing an orange for the "a" in cookadilly and then changing up the "cook" or "dilly" so one of them is more neutral. My only challenge with the logo is the colors... I want a slightly more modern feel (without losing the whimsy that you have created) so play with that. Use a neutral (like a dark brown, gray or teal) as your base then compliment from there.

Also, is it acceptable to ask for a logo with and without the steam flourish? So I could choose which one to use depending on the medium (print versus Website, for example).

Jackie
10 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Hi Jackie,

I'll make these revisions from home this evening (I'm currently at work) and submit them for your review. We'll tweak the color as many times as you want to get it just right. :)

And yes, you can have the logo with, and without the steam flourish. No problem at all.

Thanks!

Pam
10 years ago
Login
Home Start on your logo Contests Portfolio Designers Why? Help Contact Us
Forum About Us
1-800-300-3231