Thank you for the entry. I very much appreciate the ideas of stars and 5 being incorporated. This is a bit too cartoon or cute. I can see it for a child's birthday. Please see my comment in the brief that I think I need a logo that go beyond that weekend. It should not only be about a birthday but more of a symbol for the group of 5 guys.
These are cleaver as well...and you are one of the designers that is reading and noticing the feedback, what like. It still feels a little bit cartoon like or feminine...not as masculine as I would like? Needs to be more rugged...74 is stronger and closer to an old Western sign with the lines in it
Love the use of the horns and the subtle inclusion. I LOVE that you used the star that I really like but it gets a little lost behind the rest of the design.