We like something about each of your designs. Would you be able to make the "B" in Entry #31 symmetrical to the design of the "E", the same way you did in Entry #32? Make it look like a mirror image of the E on the other side of the escalator in black. And perhaps you can put the bar graph design in #30, behind the new design in grey.
Please note that at this stage of the contest only the 1st ranked designer can submit changes. If you want me to execute the changes, I would have to be ranked 1st place.
As for the changes, I will prepare them right now so they are ready when I have a green light with the ranking.
We really like the revisions. The graph in the background of #45 is perfect if you can make the grey the same hue as #32. We are also still trying to get the symmetrical 3D effect for this logo image. If you can imagine the logo spinning on an invisible post in the center of a globe and from all sides it still looks the same, this is the effect we are looking for. The B & E in designs 32 & 42-45 all work as far as symmetry. But we think this can be best achieved if you can create the B in #31 to mirror the E on the same level. Then give it that 3D effect as in #32 where it looks like is spinning around a ball with the graph sticking out of the top.
Yes!! Now if you can make the letters extend out from the circle and shade them grey as in #32 giving it that 3D effect with a white escalator in the center, I think it would be PERFECT!
WOW!! You are really talented. You have created something that I couldn't even imagine and with every revision you seem to go beyond what I initially thought. I really appreciate all the work you are doing to make it work for us. Now, I like #49 best as far as design and coloring of the letters with the white background and grey graph. I think if you can make the letters in #49 protrude outside of the circle as in #48 and shade the same colors to give that 3-D effect as if its shooting out of the globe...that may do it! I think you've got the idea that the globe is spinning on a post that is the graph sticking out of the center and it looks the same from all sides no matter how fast its spinning. Now, the B & the E just needs to look as if its raised from the surface like in #48. Ultimately, we want to create promotional merchandise such as stress balls, flags and mugs that give this effect with the logo. Thanks so much!
Thanks for the extensive feedback. I have spent several hours working on your idea to make it perfect, including work in 3D software, in order to get a real 3D-look. I am positive that this is the best that can be done.
Having said this, I hope you understand that I won't be able to make any major changes from this point on.
We love #48 most of all with the open green & white circle background. We just want you to change the colors of only the letters (2 different shades of grey as you have in #49) so the letters are 3D & distinct from the background.