#116 - WOW! We are really digging this logo. Here's our thoughts.... Christmas is a little hard to read. Can you make this contrast against the banner a little more. Can you make the gold part of the outside of the ornament have some more detail. it just needs more depth. Look at design #112, this is ideal.
Could we see the san serif letters for BIG in another design. So put the letters from #53 in this design.
What about making a small string loop through the top of the ornament and having it fall behind the design....just a thought...it looks lonely up top.
If the area of the folds on the banner (behind the words Christmas) could be a little more darker green, I think that would be great. The front banner and the back banner blend together.
Ok...think we super close. Take the design of #116 (the serif fonts works better) - Add the Christmas from #125 Leave the same banner color from #116 and remove the small lens flair from Christmas
On the pointed parts of the banner behind the ornament....just slightly darken those up so the back banner and the front banners colors don't blend.
#131 - Changes look great! Can I see it without the stroke on the outside. The top cap of the ornament is the only thing that we're not 100% about. Take a look here - http://images.efollett.com/spirit/v4/700/XM058-SP297HK1C.jpg See how the top cap had those rounded corner groves....not sure if this is possible, but we think the cap just needs some type of detail.
#130 is the same but without the extra stroke... are you wanting the gold rim removed? I can do detailed design on the cap, I have to attend to some things first, but as soon as I get back I'll make the changes