Best of SF Bay AreaLogo Design Contest

Logo Design Contest
Contests / Best of SF Bay Area

Best of SF Bay Area has selected their winning logo design.

For $275 they received 54 designs from 6 different designers from around the world.
1st
#54

Withdrawn

4th
#53

Withdrawn

5th
#48

Withdrawn

6th
#50

Withdrawn

8th
#49

Withdrawn

9th
#30

Withdrawn

10th
#43

Withdrawn

New
#44

Withdrawn

New
#31

Withdrawn

New
#42

Withdrawn

New
#45

Withdrawn

New
#46

Withdrawn

New
#47

Withdrawn

New
#33

Withdrawn

New
#13

Withdrawn

New
#16

Withdrawn

New
#36

Withdrawn

New
#32

Withdrawn

New
#37

Withdrawn

New
#34

Withdrawn

New
#35

Withdrawn

New
#10

Withdrawn

New
#9

Withdrawn

New
#4

Withdrawn

New
#14

Withdrawn

New
#15

Withdrawn

New
#12

Withdrawn

New
#11

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#41

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#8

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#7

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#6

Withdrawn

Prefers others.
#5

Discussion

 
Logo Designer
Hi Adrianne.

Thanks for reviewing my entries. I saw SF Bay Area and figured I had to join, I was raised in the and lived most my life in the Bay Area (currently in Sacramento area), but the Bay Area is what I call "home". :)

Anyway, I figured I'll throw in a few entries and see what direction to take it from there. I figured I would use the treble clef to represent music/theater/arts and the forks to represent everything dining. And of course the bridge to tie it all together. I could also add some grapes, skyline... but I wanted to keep it simple and then expand depending on what you may want to see. For entry #8 and #9 my thought was that if your reviews are broken down to day events and night life, a simple color change can of the same icon could be used.

Your feedback and thoughts would be greatly appreciated. Feel free to make any suggestions.

Thanks!

Marcelo

BTW - Are you the same Adrianne associated with the Marin Mystery Theatre?
11 years ago
 
Hi Marcelo,

Thank you for your logos, I will review them all in detail and get back to you with my comments.

Yes I am the same Adrianne with Marin Murder Mysteries, how did you hear about me?

Best,

Adrianne
11 years ago
 
Okay here goes: Not a big fan of the red and green logos / of the split night and day or that SF is being "inserted" in. Also not sure we want the sunrise or the moon in the middle...

I'd like to see all font black except "SF", with SF being the bridge red maybe?

the light blue background is good. Maybe we can see the skylines how you were describing above?
11 years ago
 
Also the "SF" can be a different font to make it stand out.. just don't really like how it looks like it was edited into the verbiage =)
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Thanks Adrianne,

Appreciate the feedback. :) I'll start making the revisions, not really a fan of the day/night split either, but I wanted to offer up a few option as starting points and ideas for more direction.

I had read about the theatre group a while back. I remember the group because there was a musician/artist that wanted to do something similar in the Bay Area back in the late 80's, but then ended moving the idea to L.A.). I used to be more in the scene when I was younger, and even had the opportunity to direct actress Rita Moreno with the cast of Beach Blanket Babylon, for a PSA when I was only 23yo. My father was in theatre before going into film production and then advertising, so it was something I was raised with.

Anyway, I see that the contest went into Top 5 so you would need to rank us in order for a a submit button to be available. I'll do a skyline, but any additional thoughts that you may have or if there are logos you have seen and really like, please let me know so I can get a better idea of the style you prefer.

Thanks

Marcelo
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Thanks for the ranking Adrianne.

I'll get the revisions going. :)

Marcelo
11 years ago
 
Can you change #10 to not have a black background?

Can I see the size of the letters on 13 with 16 background? and also with the blue background or maybe a green?
11 years ago
 
What about adding a trolley car somewhere? maybe in the skyline or lose the skyline and add a trolley?
11 years ago
 
Ok we like 30 the best so far, like the skyline in the orange / red but the trolley should be a different color.. more like a fire engine red and yellowish wood color (google the SF trolleys)... and we like the black outline of 31... can you incorporate all of this into 1? And maybe the trolley bigger like in 31..
11 years ago
 
Oh and maybe can you show an option of the above with fog under the bridge or somewhere?
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Hi Adrianne,

No problem on all counts. :) I have plenty of trolly pictures for reference. I was not to sure if I should limit the color or not. I'll redo them to reflect the cable cars more realistically. Also, my intention on the blue to white fade was symbolic of the fog, but I do a version a bit more pronounced like this ( http://3ef44ac2a814e81509fd-288404e13f895703cf2798bf6ae95228.r56.cf1.rackcdn.com/758851227787-223.png ). I'll also do a few more colors in the mix, just to see how that looks.

Thanks again, your feedback has been great!

Marcelo
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Hi Adrianne,

I hope I got the instructions right. For #42 I extended the blue (sky) to white (fog) fade to make it more pronounced then my earlier renditions. On others I added the fog billow (let me know if you feel that they obscure the fork too much). Also, for #41 I curved the trolly for a more cartoony feel (just as an option).

Let me know if you need any other changes or if I missed anything.

Thanks.

If you celebrate it... Happy Easter to you and your family. :)

Marcelo
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Hello again Adrianne,

Please let me know if you would like to see other versions, colors, fonts...


Thanks

Marcelo
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Hi Adrianne,

Are you waiting for some other changes or new ideas? I'm not sure if I missed something, please let me know and I get them going for you. :)

Thanks

Marcelo
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Hi Adrianne,

Are you waiting for some other changes or new ideas? I'm not sure if I missed something, please let me know and I get them going for you. :)

Thanks

Marcelo
11 years ago
 
Hi Marcelo,

So sorry for the delay.. I was ill end of last week and we had our baby shower this weekend.. I will get back to you ASAP with final decisions.. etc.. we had the contest ended a few days only so I can have you fine tune the logo =)

Best,

A

11 years ago
 
can I see #45 and #42 with a more SF giants(ish) SF?

also what do you think about adding a wine bottle as a building in the skyline?
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
No problem Adrianne,

I hope your feeling better. I just wanted to be sure, that I did not miss something you were waiting for. I'll make the SF with a more collegiate look. (We can't use make it too precise as it might violate their trademark.)

As with the bottle, I'll try both the bottle in the building silhouette , and the build as a bottle.

BTW - I believe a congratulations is in order for you and your husband :)

Marcelo
11 years ago
 
I like the new SF better but don't like the trolley cutting the bridge off.. #48 is the best so far fro the wine bottles, but maybe too many wine bottles. can you remove the one in front and the 2 on the left.. just keeping the one on the right. Make trolley not cut off bridge like in #45 and #42
11 years ago
 
OH and 1 last thing.. I would like the font without the drop shadow effect.. more like #45 aside from the SF which is perfect!
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Hi Adrianne,

#54 has a black outline around "SF" and trolley slightly higher than #53.

Thanks again.

Marcelo
11 years ago
 
#54 it is! great thank you so much!
Will you be able to send me the low and high res PDFs as well as InDesign files? once I select this as the winner of course?
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Sure Adrianne,

After the contest end files must be upload is both an EPS and JPEG so the Logotournament automated process is completed. However, as most designers, I usually also send additional files as png, pdf and the the original Adobe Illustrator file. These additional files must be emailed directly to you after the contest is complete and the LT files have been uploaded. The eps can be used for placing in InDesign, the native files can also be cut and pasted into InDesign, so that should not be a problem. :)

Thanks

Marcelo
11 years ago
 
Great thank you!

Oh and you asked if I was the Adrianne from the Mystery Theatre.. how did you hear about me?
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Hi again,

I heard about you when I read about the Mystery Theatre. (See my comment above). What I did not realize until a couple of weeks back, is that you had the logo for the Mystery Theatre done here on Logotournament. I'm glad you came back to use LT again.

If there is any other thing you need to see changed, just be sure to ask.

Thanks

Marcelo

11 years ago
Login
Home Start on your logo Contests Portfolio Designers Help Contact Us
Forum About Us
1-800-300-3231