Hi Sam, Here is the logo idea I came up with for your website. I wanted to create a strong emblem that could be place throughout your site, as well as on others for advertising. This bold crest icon would look great on hats, shirts, etc. too! I also tried to make it feel neutral in terms of the Cards, D-Backs, Wildcats, etc. without leaning too heavily towards any particular team. Let me know what you think and if you wish to see any changes (color or otherwise), and I will be happy to work on some variations.
Also, I noticed your current logo is on a red background, so I pull those colors from your site and show you how this would look against that as well.
As I mentioned, here is the crest on the same shade of background as your current logo. The white border allows the logo to look great and showup on virtually any color background.
After looking at your site again, I realized a more horizontal layout is a better fit for the space you have available. I also added the slogan as well, so you can see how it would look if you included that.