Great responses so far! #10 is the only one which really connects with what I'm looking for.
Some further refinements:
- I like the very abstract foot, Could play with wider, narrower, etc.
- Keep left left root. A right foot doesn't look right.
- font color/bold should somehow emphasize "animal" part rather than "a" or "better"
- not sure about claws of a different color, maybe see what they also look like in blue
- possible to have 4 smaller claws curved inwards, then big toe claw slightly outwards? (similar to this...
http://www.hairribbons.com/newweb/images/temporary_tattoos/bear_claw_tattoos_black.jpg )
I'm looking forward to your designs!