I like #12, but it looks kind of sparse and angular. As a start, perhaps strengthen/thicken some elements and switch to your font from #2 and #3. See what you can do to "make it pop".
The amber might need to be darker to show up better on a white background.
I kind of like the recycling triangle pointing to the right- that's a nice addition.
I also like the circular mark's resemblance to the organic logo:
http://easywaystogogreen.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/04/4colorsealjpg.jpg (because a lot of our customers are organic farmers)
#11 is "stronger", but otherwise I don't like it as much.
Thanks again. Keep 'em coming. So far, you're the only one who is really sticking to my guidelines.