Your new entries are AWESOME! I really like where this is going.
Feedback:
Your color scheme seems to be more saltwater than freshwater, so I'd like to see more dark colors (black, brown, and green) where possible. And if you can turn one of the fish into a largemouth bass, and one into a smallmouth bass or walleye, that might be a great look as well.
Also, your worm-on-a-hook depiction gave me confidence in you (moreso than all of the other designers) to create an emblem for the company: A worm dangling from a hook in the letter "W". And maybe the hook can be a lowercase "g". Although it might look best with the worm forming JUST a "W", or the worm forming a "W" and a "G".
You're the artist! Make it happen :)