I like #5 and #4, but remove the words "school district"....just say West Platte Blue Jays. Also, try to make the blue jay a little more traditional. See the sample pictures...there is one that shows the blue jay head shot in the corner of a banner. That's the one most people in the community really like; however, he's too dated. He needs some upgrades. It is okay to just create a head shot too. I'm thinking classic...and updated.
Thanks!