#6 This is closest to what we're looking for right now. We're looking for something that says a little we're more "local", but this is a good direction to start in.
#5 We like how this refers to a book presence as well, since the totallocal.com logo refers to the online presence for our printed telephone books/community resource guides - however, this seems to say more of an industral feel to us rather than a local, small-town feel.